So often in my dreams

I hold you close against my skin

Waking up I wish that I could

Sleep and dream again



Cause only when I sleep

Can I not hear how it's a sin

How cheaters never win

Their heartaches never end



"Torn Between Two Lovers" on the jukebox

And I'm thinking how I could've wrote that song

Wonderin' if God loves us, when we're cheatin'

But why he lets us feels things if it's wrong



I guess I should be singing "Rock of Ages"

"Amazing Grace", some of those good songs

Can't find it in my heart to ask forgiveness

Anything that feels this right can't be that wrong



Thou shalt not commit it

It's written in the tin

The spirit is always willing

But the flesh is weak again



And you're as close to heaven

As I might ever fly

An angel in disguise

A wrong that feels so right



And Torn Between Two Lovers just keeps playing

And I don't wanna be right if lovin' you is wrong

It goes against all I've ever stood for

Knowin' I have someone else at home



I guess I should be singing "Rock of Ages"

"Amazing Grace", some of those good songs

But my cheatin' heart can tell on me tomorrow

Cause anything that feels this right can't be that wrong



To hell with heaven if it means I'll lose you

Anything that feels this right can't be that wrong

It just can't be